Since 20 October 2010, I have been reading for comprehensive exams.
The PhD in Human Geography at the University of British Columbia requires three exams to be written in the second year of the PhD. These three exams address three broad fields that will be addressed in the dissertation and that can serve as broad teaching areas for a future career in academia.
My exams are set for 17-21 January 2011. I sit one exam for each of 17, 19, and 21 January. These are written, take-home exams where I have to answer two questions about a broad field in human geography; the normal length of each answer is a 7-10 page literature review. On the following week, I also sit a three-hour oral exam with my doctoral comprehensive exam committee. Currently, my doctoral committee consists of: David Ley (UBC Geography), David Edgington (UBC Geography), Henry Yu (UBC History), and Claire Dwyer (University College London, Geography).
The rumour has gone around UBC that the Geography exams are among the most difficult in the Faculty of Graduate Studies. I cannot confirm the truth of this rumour, but what I can say is that it is simultaneously difficult and rewarding. The aim of these exams is to give a broad understanding of the field and to invite interdisciplinary approaches to the subject matter (which only goes to show how interdisciplinary Geography is as a discipline!).
The three fields I will sit are as follows:
COMPREHENSIVE EXAM #1:
GEOGRAPHIES OF RELIGION, SECULARISM AND SOCIAL THEORY
- “Old” and “New” Cultural Geographies of Religion (the “old” refers to the Berkeley school of cultural geography led by Carl Sauer, the “new” to Jim Duncan’s turn toward process in the politics of placemaking)
- Theories of religion
- Anthropological and sociological approaches to religion
- Political constructions of secularity
- Islam and the West: liberal, feminist, and ethnographic approaches
- Religion and transnational migration
- Congregational studies (i.e. R. Stephen Warner’s “new paradigm”)
Major thinkers I address in this list include a diverse range: Wilbur Zelinsky, David E. Sopher, Lily Kong, Reinhard Henkel, Peter E. Hopkins, David Ley, Claire Dwyer, Kevin Dunn, Banu Gokariksel, Philip Kelly, Paul Bramadat, R. Stephen Warner, Helen Rose Ebaugh, Janet Chafetz, Peggy Levitt, Steven Vertovec, Peter Berger, Harvey Cox, Emile Durkheim, Mircea Eliade, Clifford Geertz, William James, Rudolf Otto, Karl Marx, Rodney Stark, Max Weber, Talal Asad, Jose Casanova, Michel Foucault, Jurgen Habermas, Stanley Hauerwas, John Milbank, and Charles Taylor.
While religion is the major focus of the list, such a diversity of sources also enables a broader address of the following in future research and teaching:
- social and cultural geography
- intellectual histories of the social sciences
- multiculturalism and migration studies
COMPREHENSIVE EXAM #2:
PACIFIC WORLDS IN MOTION: ASIAN MIGRATIONS AND GEOGRAPHIES OF MIGRATION AND ETHNICITY
- Theories of international migration
- The “mobilities” paradigm (John Urry)
- Multicultural theory and policy
- Labour migrations
- Transnational migration studies
- Second-generation issues
- Asian American studies
- Race theory and race studies
- Asian Canadian studies
- Pacific Rim studies
Major thinkers I address include: Stephen Castles, Mark J. Miller, Catherine Bretell, James Frank Hollifield, Nancy Foner, John Urry, Ghassan Hage, Robert Putnam, Brenda Yeoh, Katie Willis, Christian Joppke, David Ley, Nina Glick Schiller, Linda Basch, Christina Szanton Blanc, Elaine Ho, Peggy Levitt, Mary C. Waters, Aihwa Ong, Ien Ang, Laurence Ma, Carolyn Cartier, Ronald Takaki, Glenn Omatsu, Sucheng Chan, Lisa Lowe, Jack Tchen, Robert G. Lee, Henry Yu, Helen Zia, Kay Anderson, Dorothy Fujita-Rony, Madeline Hsu, Alexander Saxton, Judy Yung, Peter Ward, Patricia Roy, Charles A. Price, Eiichiro Azuma, Carlos Bulosan, Yen Le Espiritu, Vijay Prashad, Chris Lee, and Peter Li.
While Pacific migrations and ethnicities are the major foci of the list, this list also enables me to address the following in future research and teaching:
- Globalization theory
- Citizenship in theory and practice
- Global economics and geopolitics
- Theories of social and cultural capital
- Race and ethnic politics
COMPREHENSIVE EXAM #3
CITIES IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC: HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVES
- Asian cities in global and regional contexts
- Colonial and post-colonial cities
- Global cities/world cities
- Pacific Rim studies
- Cities and the welfare state in post-colonial Asia
- Cities and the neoliberal state in post-colonial Asia
- Convergence/divergence theory (e.g. Terry McGee’s desakota model)
- Garden cities and urban utopias
- Sustainable cities
- Rural-urban relations and migrations
- Labour in Asian cities
- Urban development in Asia
Major thinkers I address are: Terry McGee, David Edgington, W.B. Kim, Anthony King, Fucheng Lo, Peter Marcotullio, Karen Y.P. Lai, Saskia Sassen, Brenda Yeoh, Fulong Wu, S.O. Park, Ryan Bishop, Abidin Kusno, Laurence Ma, Kris Olds, Manuel Castells, H.W. Dick, P.J. Rimmer, Michael Douglass, G.L. Ooi, John Gugler, Jonathan Rigg, Andrew Sorenson, and Dean Forbes.
Though the list focuses on Asian cities in particular, broader areas for future writing and teaching include:
- Comparative Asian, North American, and European cities
- Migrant labour
- Pacific and Pacific Rim studies
- Urban sustainability
- Theories of “orientalism”
- Colonial and post-colonial studies
- State politics: welfare and neoliberal models
So now…it’s back to reading! The labour is rewarding, the knowledge both intellectually stimulating and relevant to the contemporary situation.